okay thank you. I will move to public comment period
and this is the time to remember the public members of the public who wish to
be heard on matters that do not appear in the agenda and pursuant to City
Council resolution 2011 - 22 a City Council policy is limit each speaker to
three minutes and such time allotment or portion thereof so not be transferred
other speakers the public will be allowed to speak concurrently with the
calling of a agenda item following the staff temptation of that idea and
pursuant to the Brown Act the City Council cannot take action on any item
that does not appear on the agenda so like to address the council go ahead and
step forward. Good evening Mr. Mayor, ladies and gentlemen of the council. Yes
I am a board member of HSAA, Homeless Students Advocacy Alliance. The
seating is for 300. Thank you for announcing that. I am here tonight to
speak on a very sensitive subject. It is on the criminalization of
homelessness... and what this city has been doing... and what hasn't been doing. We have
been before this council. I've been here since November of this 2017. We've asked
for agendized items for homelessness to be put on the agenda...to no avail. There
has not been. And I have been doing some record searches in regards to specific.
All tickets and citations under the "arrest," and "arrest for panhandling,"
"aggressive solicitation" [force] set forth in the city of Eureka Municipal Code as
of January 1st 2016 ...April...through April 30th of 2017, 78 cases have been filed. I
would like to also remind you and I will give you this as a document. Challenges...
bans restrictions of panhandling. Cases in from 2013 through 2015... First circuit...
Fourth circuit... Sixth... Seventh Circuit Tenth Circuit and Eleventh Circuit deems
it unconstitutional. I have also made a records request as of December 4th 2017.
As of January 1 2016 through April 30th of 2017. 976 arrests... or excuse me... I
apologize... cases have been cited to homeless people for camping in public. I
would like to refer to a document called California New Vagrancy laws. The
growing encampment enforcement of anti homeless laws in the Golden State. This
was released February 2015 from Berkeley law school. And the statement of interest
that was given by the United States Department of Justice. I have filed this
with the civil grand jury... hand-delivered this to the grand jury foreman as of two
days ago. I made a presentation to the Human Rights Commission. And my intention
is to ask this council to immediately put this upon an agendized item and ask for
a willful moratorium on the six ordinances that you have that
criminalizes homelessness. I will be at this point making the declaration to the
complaint about law enforcement officers and law enforcement agencies with the
California Department of Justice. And I will leave that document with you also.
And I encourage you to meet with me with the press after this forum. Thank
you so much for your time, your concern, and your consideration on this matter.
And if there's any questions I'll be glad to address those. Thank you for your
time. Thank you
good evening city council mayor city manager my name is John sheltered New
Directions program and a lot of people thought I'd be upset that you guys
invited the downtown streets team into town but instead I'm actually kind of
excited because it shows seven years ago we had back to basics at the North Coast
Resource Center in Arcata we ran that program for $225,000 a year
providing food boxes for the low-income families sixty showers hot meals for
anywhere from 150 to 200 people the big thing is is that we've already done that
and been there I know them just as well their program because when we shut our
doors at North Coast Resource Center they had just started the coyote Creek
project if we look at their budget and all their other remember paperwork that
they've shared out the big difference between New Directions and the downtown
streets team is that the city's supported them the county supported them
recreation supported them public works - supported them homelessness affects each
and every one of our departments in all of our cities I think there are some
jobs out there that maybe the homeless can do are willing to do and can thrive
that we need to really start looking at self-supporting not bringing another
nonprofit in but look at what we can get for a return on our dollar New
Directions has never asked for a penny all we ask for is work we work hard we
pay our homeless they move from their tents and move forward in their lives
this isn't about New Directions this is about making the right decisions why
would we want to bring in somebody from Santa Cruz or wherever they come from
originally to teach our homeless what to do when we already have a Bible program
here that's already experienced and grown out of their stage into the
self-supporting stage isn't that what we want in our communities
we want the homeless to work their way back and they are willing to if we give
them the opportunities unfortunately new directions just a small little business
because in 2011 our board decided that employing the homeless was too risky too
much of a liability that's not true seven years later we have not had a
workman's comp claim or unemployment claim now maybe some could but they
never did because they thrived they moved back with family members they
moved on our program doesn't work for everybody just like their program
probably doesn't work for everybody but it's sure a better start guys I thank
you so much and you guys are a lot smarter than I am so let's put our heads
together and figure out why we're not involved thank you thank you good
evening mayor council my name is Sean Swanson I'm the founder of River Life
Foundation from Fortuna I've worked with John shelter for the last I would say
just about six years for about a year I worked for John I'm heading up his
cruise when we did the spartina on the safety corridor I'm the only reason why
I ended up leaving John is because the government shutdown and the funding for
that program ended up ending during that time we had helped several people get
out of whether they were living in motels living in the brush John gave
them a chance gave them a hand up not a hand out and helped to change many lives
I personally now work for a construction company unfortunate and then I also run
River Life River Life Foundation uses John shelters guys they come down they
volunteer for when we do our River Bar cleanups they have also been paid to do
river bar cleanups when we can afford to do it they've also come to my personal
residence and mode mode my Hill and very respectful do you awesome jobs the these
guys that he gets or have been downtrodden I've been homeless myself so
I know what it's like to be totally lost with nothing
John helps to provide hope just as River Life Foundation provides hope River Life
Foundation has gotten 131 people out of the area reunited with family or on two
jobs in the Fortuna area we've cleaned up two hundred and seventy-six thousand
pounds of trash that's because awesome volunteers that help get awesome stuff
done John shelter and new directions is a positive force in Eureka and the
community of Humboldt thank you very much
Good evening. My name is Jimmy work
Homelessness [ [gentleman] shelter America myself. You know the
Constitution is a pretty simple document. You know you can't just keep taking our
stuff every week. You can't just... you hunt us down down...down the Hikshari' Trail, and
this [Gator] they have. I see grown men and women sitting there like feral animals.
Their ears perk up to the sound of a motor. They run. Why? We didn't do anything wrong.
We're not trespassing. You took it. You took our stuff from us. What do you think
we're gonna do? Let our families go without? No we're gonna go get more
however we can. We're not the cause of the crime. You are. You make policy.
Policies and force... those jackbooted thugs you have running around doing this... insulting
us personally. Making it a personal issue. And you grant and empower personal
persuasion instead of political influence... or personal influence instead of
professional power. No one is stupid . Everyone knows what that means. I
mean what have we done so wrong to you? I'm a 17 year combat veteran of the United
States Army. This is my home. Who gave you the right to wake up one day and tell me
I'm not welcome. Who gave you the authority to adopt a self deportation
policy? What gave you the right? I gave you that right not to abuse it. That's
all you've done. You've taken my wife from me. She was gonna die outside. She was taken
from me. We didn't do anything wrong. She was taken by you. And then you take high
umbrage when people get offended. But every document that comes out of this
building that affects my life that makes it worse has your signature on it. And
you sit there and clear consciences... I don't see how you do it. Every citizen shall
be secure in their persons, dwellings, papers, and their effects.
You should not be infringed upon without substantial due process. [Neither] shall agents be
sent forth. Where are the warrants? Where are the affidavits?
Where is the due process? If you're gonna eradicate me... do it openly... publicly. Where's
the accountability? I have no quarrel with you. I didn't start anything with
you. But you've taken everything from me and you still take. You know I'm gonna
die out here. I'm going to die out here alone. I wonder how long my body's gonna be
bloated and eaten by animals until I'm found. Then will they even be able to
identify me? You know. I'm gonna get a brick over my head somewhere... with John Doe
Number 84 on it. If people want to thank me for my service... you should apologize.
You guys need to make things right. You're doing it wrong. And you know it.
Over half the nation is united against this type of action. I mean I make a lot
of people angry and I'm pretty abrasive. But come on... you guys are overachievers. Over
half the United States is upset with these policies. And you can't see that as
wrong. Come on. Stand up and be counted. Be accountable. Do something.
Thank you.
me yoga counselors in city manager my name's Donna Wright and I'm the
executive director at the Eureka Chamber of Commerce
I'd like to endorse the work of new directions and under the leadership of
John shelter six months ago the chamber had a large financial commitment to a
company for the well-being of our staff and visitors not including cleanup after
meeting with John and setting clear needs guidelines and boundaries to
assist with the homeless problem we were experienced almost immediately we found
new direction dramatically reduced people camping loitering and while we've
had the occasional problems and we've had the support of the police we have
dramatically reduced our costs additionally they do the cleanup for us
as well the reduce the costs and we now work in a safe clean environment so I
just like to endorse them
homelessness I am again asking for your support for that I also noticed on the
consent calendar is the agenda are not the attend to the minutes from your
strategic planning sessions the two days that you met to do strategic planning
and the first day that I was there there was a lot of people council members
voicing concern about homeless issues and people I think at the Town Hall took
exception to me saying that you hadn't been talking about homelessness but when
you talk about housing that is a solution to homelessness but that's a
long-term solution and something needs to be done now so when I applied for the
committee I was very open with them and said that I want to work on a camp and
that was a brave thing to do because half the nation is not with me on this
and I'm like mister it is not a popular position to be and to advocate for a
camp but that is not what I want but that is what is needed right now there
are people out subject to the laws that the were talk to you about and they need
a legal place to be so again I'm asking you to support my appointment to that
Commission or that committee it's I will resend it to you I heard that
they're not going to be making the appointments until next month so you
have some time thank you
good evening thank you for letting me come before you my name's Harry Wilcox I
live on n Street here in Eureka I love this city on private city I'm a
transplant from New York City I'm here again to talk about the ordinance that
we passed here a little while ago and the results of it is if you look on the
website for Hatcher's they print it up what I can only call this just cook
numbers I mean they won't even try to explain their numbers to you you call
them you contact them they can't tell you where they got those numbers from I
believe that they're including numbers from people like myself who volunteer
without that meaning to pick up needles and dispose of them or give them to them
some diabetic needles I believe are thrown in there but there's no way
they're doing anything I live right between Ross Park and Cooper's Gulch my
backyard is Cooper's Gulch I never see anybody down there as a group or
otherwise identifying themselves of being from Hatcher collecting needles
and I mean I can walk right along path and pick them up my dog stepped on one
thank God he didn't get anything but I'm here again to say we have got to put
some teeth in that measure we've got to revisit it put some teeth in it and make
these people yes I know there's more than this subject that had your handles
but I go to NA meetings I talk to people they have never tried to get those
people when they were active to go into rehab or any other program it's here
here's your needles were busy and that's a fact that's no bull crap what you see
online you go to their site that recent report I think they should have come
before the council and given that report not just release it on some website
hoping no one would see it and blow it under the table and I think that's part
of what we need to do is require them to come before this council and account for
the needles that they give out the needles they take in how they're break
it down for us you know I've volunteer to pick up
needles all the time yeah volunteering for Eureka is fine but if I got a spin
on my time picking up needles keep kids safe I ain't got time to go out and do
all this beautification stuff I'm doing my share by walking the streets and pick
it up the needles and chasing the bums out of the park thank you for your time
appreciate it else want to address the council on a non-agenda item evening
council mayor Bob Toole I want to thank Allison or Austin for bringing up this
climate change we're in trouble if it actually happens and Natalie for
bringing up your subject too but what I'd like to see is the council get back
to council reports your committee reports I haven't heard any of you give
a committee report that you're on for I don't know how long and I'd like to see
you get back to that put this other stuff on it on an agenda item so that
everybody has a chance to see it go over it and go from there but stick to your
council reports and I think it would be a lot better I'm glad he brought up the
needle exchange again again I direct your attention to that handout I give
you the work order work done on that ordinance and we do need some strict
teeth in there I looked at that report from Hatcher online and a lot of other
people have done it the numbers just don't add up and something has to be
done yesterday I walked the railroad track between T Street and Blue Ox
I picked up five bags of those easy touch syringe bags that have been
discarded luckily I didn't find any needles I was shocked
but I did find one needle down by the Eureka boiler works and the owner there
Dale Holger brought it to my attention and I put my gloves on and got my sharps
container and picked it up but something has to be done with this needle exchange
get some teeth in that ordinance and start enforcing it anyone else want
address the council at this time y'all can do better I know it was a rush to
get it off of your agenda it was obvious from the fact that some
wanted to table it and others wanted it push through it was obvious from the
fact that you did it without all of the facts in place you didn't have the
answer to the question where does the control of the needle exchange reside
Matt Cain from the office of AIDS will do everything he can to avoid answering
that question he will tell you I can't answer that it's for lawyers to tell you
but the dots are there to connect the state has authorized needle exchanges
before the most prominent example being Orange County Orange County was voted
out of existence by their local board control of needle exchanges resides at
the local level so you'd needn't feared that and if you
had tabled it you would have known I do ask that you revisit the pharmacy sales
question I know that you can't stop pharmacy sales but it would be nice to
have a number it would be a simple matter of asking the pharmacies to
establish a separate UPC code they can track how many they're selling that way
and we'd have a number and we'd have a way of knowing what are we picking up
are we picking up Hatcher needles are these pharmacy
and if there's more pharmacy needles out there than we guessed we need to start
addressing the people buying there and getting them to Hatcher or the county or
somebody that can start getting them on a path to wellness you can do better
please do anyone else want to address the council on a non-agenda item okay
seeing no one will close the cover comment period and move to hearing this
I didn't expect to speak...but hearing this... what's been talked about. I think that if there's programs like new directions...
just think of the number of needles there'd be without them. I don't think
that they're spending their time you know lollygagging around. They're
in their work for a reason. It's not easy work. So without that there'd be even
more needles. And really a tiny house village or three... maybe one just
specifically for people needing to recoup from mental health issues would
go a long way to solve a lot of these issues. Because the only people suffering
more than those picking up needles are those shoving them into their veins to
try to mitigate the pain of running from police.
Mandatory medications... very little psychological support. And what support
there is... doesn't do much good when people are hiding in the bushes... or in
their vehicles... And as far as it's great there's programs like New Directions but
when you think about hand up versus hand out... where did your bootstraps come from?
What got you to where you are today? Because I think everyone who's anywhere
has gotten some handouts. And a lot of the people who are homeless have already
cleaned homes and done landscaping and cleaned up city streets and done all
sorts of things. And one too many traumas... one too many things maybe you can't even
imagine... a lot of the people that are homeless are from the foster system. They
have alumnies back from the day when there wasn't as many programs as there are now.
There are still not enough for the orphans... which are
euphemistically called foster children... except for no disrespect to the parents
who still want and should be having their children in their custody.
So really mental health hasn't been discussed here. And the terror of being
homeless and hiding and feeling like a criminal when all you need is a place to
rest and recoup and heal. That just isn't acceptable and I think it's
affecting all of our health. And so I hope something's collectively done about
it. And the tiny-house village seems like a great proven thing done elsewhere and
maybe more than one. thank you thank you
my name's Mike Oakland resident marquita I wanted to bring up an issue that is a
public health issue involving the medical partnership and denti-cal
situation here in Humboldt County where there's really only one facility in this
area who has not accepted any adult patients and somewhere around a decade
somewhere around ten years notice to say that they are not a designated pediatric
facility and they do have existing adult patients but they will not allow any new
adult patient over the age of 19 but if you're under the age of 19
they'll accept you at any time as far as I'm concerned that is discrimination
based upon age they can accept new patients if you're understand under 18
so they have the ability to take in new people and they're not a pediatric
facility so they do have adult existing patients but they won't accept anybody
over the age of 19 and that's been like that for somewhere upwards of 10 years I
spoke to a local news agency this afternoon I also spoke to a replica
representative from the administrative office of the open door
senator and they acknowledge that this is a serious problem but a serious
problem that hasn't been addressed and all in upwards of a decade it effects
you know I don't know exactly how many people but everybody that are you know
these are low-income people that are on Medicare under the denti-cal beneficiary
program that are not getting adequate medical care and I think that it's
something that needs to be addressed on a more prominent level and so I'm
presenting it here tonight so that you guys are aware of this existing problem
and that hopefully we can find a solution that is suitable for the
community because right now people in order to get any kind of care you have
to travel outside of the area in fact that you have to go to read way or Hoopa
and read way doesn't accept any new patients either and I'm not even sure
about Hoopoe but it's probably the same thing so and just in closing mr. Allison
I'd like to speak after to speak with your energy
thank you. good evening. it's nice to see you. it's been a long time since I've
been here . may 2nd will be two years since Paco Marsh... as push... you've pushed
everybody to the streets. and I've been watching and listening and I hear that
we have a crisis. they're in every way in this city. and I've been waiting. for two
years we've been waiting. and the thought of 900 tickets. what concerns me on that
is that what we're doing to the people in breaking them down...it...with that
criminalization. but also the money that you're spending has got to be in the
millions of dollars - to do this. and it's not working. and I think that if you
talk to anybody that lives here or drives through here or comes to the
music festivals will tell you it's not working. because what we have done is... you
have taken them from one area and put them in the streets. and you've put them
on everybody's doorsteps. and I know because my children live here and I deal
with them every day. but what we need is a place for them to go. so the money that
we spent in law enforcement which has to be in the millions in the last two years.
I'd like to look at that. we should look at those figures and maybe
it would be more convincing. but we could use that money to put them in a place
where they're safe. I watched yesterday the police harass people for sitting,
laying down, and I and I get it. we don't want them laying down on our streets. and
doing all those things. but we have to give them a place to do that. so thank
you. it's good to see you. it's nice to see you mayor. and I wish you well. thank
you
hello I haven't been here for a while because I was having some trouble with
my foot. so it's pretty interesting to come back. and what I want to say is if
it's anybody's fault... because we're all blaming... it's mine because I can think of
a million things I could or should be doing. but I think the real key is not
about blame it's about taking responsibility... shared responsibility and
I'm thrilled to hear about the summit. Lynette Mullen made a terrific
presentation at the board of supervisors. but this is what has concerned me from
the beginning and I think we need to look at it. and I hope that people
watching will consider this. that the housing first strategy the focus
strategy with good intentions with love and hope in your heart sets out policies
which have ended up leading to where we're now criminalizing demonizing and
letting people on the street with no hope. and what it says is that she
actually doesn't even have a policy for emergency care. but she says she
discourages it .and said that there should not no offering services that in
creating legalized... expanding emergency shelter capacity. she talks against that
but. she also talks against evicting people. which we did. and then later. at
January 26. and I keep bringing this up because I think it's so important. she
actually said when she was asked whether you should have an emergency respons.e
she said in a flippant manner. you can look at it it's January 26. because on
the one hand people die outside and that happens all the time
homeless people die outside and they die for lots of reasons but if they weren't
outside in many cases they wouldn't have died right. she has I have a transcript
at that presentation. it is a powerful one that she made to the board. lots of
great ideas that I think we should go back and look and Institute. and you
know and adopt and I'm thrilled about the summit. but the thing is why would we
even think it's okay to arrest people outside because we think they've made
some kind of choice that they're criminals that they're less than human... you know
less than human and you know if you watched the January 9th 2018
presentation heroically... the county staff
Connie Beck said that they can only help the people that they're mandated to help
and Sally Hewitt was also you know I'll give her title because I'm always
forgetting titles bare with me here... but but she talked
about she's with it she was a program manager with with the Department of
Health and Human Services she said that if people don't have money for rent
they can't help them .so and if you call the Eureka rescue mission I think it's a
terrific organization I celebrate everybody who helps people who need help.
but we're leaving people outside and what I'm asking for as as a community as
a council we start to care about it instead of having a policy of
disappearing people arresting them demonizing. and one woman that I talked
to on the board said she often thinks about killing herself and she's a
vibrant vital interesting person and this is what's happening. people are
losing faith and hope. they're being shunned they're being chased around by
the police. they're being arrested and cited .and they're made to feel like
they're subhuman. and nothing good comes of thank you thank you thank you for not
turning off my mic. does anyone else want to address the council on a non-agenda
item okay so you know one we closed a public comment period and move to public
hearings Wendy
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét